FinanceCreated 7/1/1996
Go to Brad DeLong's
Home Page
Basics:
Exam:
Not good at knowing when your calculator has betrayed you; little sense of what answer should be. Little sense of the relationship between variance of securities, variance of portfolios, and betas...
No Black Boxes:
A black box is something that we accept and use but do not understand. We have been treating capital porjects as black boxes--but a good financial manager should never accept black boxes.
Techniques for project analysis:
Sensitivity Analysis:
An electric car project:
Year 0 |
Years 1-10 | |
| Investment | - $150 |
|
| Revenue | $375 | |
| Variable Cost | -$300 | |
| Fixed Cost | -$30 | |
| Depreciation | -$15 | |
| Pretax Profit | $30 | |
| Tax | - $15 | |
| Net Profit | $15 | |
| Operating Cash Flow | $30 | |
| Net Cash Flow | -$150 |
$30 |
Assuming that the investment is depreciated straight-line over ten years, and that corporate income is taxed at a rate of 50%.
With a 10% opportunity cost of capital, NPV = -150 +sum(i=1 to 10, $30/((1.10)t)) = +$34.3. Should you invest? The right answer is that you should make your forecasting staff do more work:
Variable |
Pessimistic |
Expected |
Optimistic |
| Market size | +$11 |
+$34 |
+$57 |
| Market share | -$104 |
+$34 |
+$173 |
| Unit price | -$42 |
$34 |
+$50 |
| Unit variable cost | -$150 |
+$34 |
+$111 |
| Fixed cost | +$4 |
+$34 |
+$65 |
The project is by no means a sure thing--if you can find information to improve your forecasts of unit variable costs and of market share, you should do so.
Limits to sensitivity analysis: what does "optimistic" mean?
What if variables are interrelated? Scenarios. Different consistent combinations.
Break-Even Analysis