« Asset Returns and Economic Growth: Full Draft | Main | We Mourn... »
March 24, 2005
The White House Thinks About the Clawback
Greg Ip and Jackie Calmes of the Wall Street Journal report signs of thought about issues of substance inside the White House:
WSJ.com - Bush May Alter Private-Accounts Plan: As currently envisioned, an account-holder would need a real return -- that is, return after inflation -- of 3% to exceed the offset in the traditional benefit. But many outside experts say 3% is too high, and will limit the accounts' appeal. They noted Treasury bonds are now expected to return only about 2%, and stocks a few percentage points more. Thus, a private account of half stocks and half bonds would run a significant risk of returning less than 3%, leaving the account-holder worse off than someone who stuck with the traditional benefit.
Some experts have urged the administration to use a lower offset rate. That would make the accounts costlier to finance as long as Social Security sticks to its assumption that real Treasury yields average 3% in the long run.
Mr. Hubbard said the administration picked 3% because Social Security actuaries estimate that figure to be the government's long-term cost of borrowing. It is the figure that makes private accounts 'fiscally neutral,' he said.... Mr. Bush's proposed accounts are closely patterned on the second of his 2001 Social Security commission's three proposals, although that model used a 2% offset rate. A former administration official says a change to the offset rate to between 2% and 3% has been discussed, with special attention on 2.7%.
It really does look as if they chose 3%, and then never ran the numbers--never ran the numbers at all to see what the distribution of private account returns would be.
One underlying problem, of course, is that private accounts shift risk onto beneficiaries, and that beneficiaries are more averse to risk than the government. Thus it is genuinely hard to make private accounts both attractive to those non-rich beneficiaries who are most averse to risk and also fiscally neutral.
Posted by DeLong at March 24, 2005 01:35 PM
Trackback Pings
TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.j-bradford-delong.net/cgi-bin/mt_2005-2/mt-tb.cgi/567
Listed below are links to weblogs that reference The White House Thinks About the Clawback:
» ashlee simpson photos from ashlee simpson photos
Victoria silvstedt nude amanda bynes nude, kate beckinsale nude michelle vieth video gratis. Britney spears porn jenna jameson pictures, victoria silvstedt nude christina ricci nude. Britney spears porn alyssa milano nude, britney spears pics chy... [Read More]
Tracked on April 23, 2005 01:44 PM
» black rape from black rape
Rape pics free rape pictures, rape cartoons rape survivor stories. Rape victims stories of rape, bondage rape true rape stories. Anal rape interracial rape, teen rape hentai rape. Asian rape teen rape, girl rape forced sex videos. Free rape do... [Read More]
Tracked on April 24, 2005 05:20 AM
» free rape movies from free rape movies
Fantasy rape stories rape websites with screams, rape cartoons japanese rape. Rape pics free rape clips, forced sex stories rape websites with screams. Women rape free rape clips, forced sex stories free rape sex. How to rape erotic rape stories... [Read More]
Tracked on May 23, 2005 03:25 PM