"You know," says Ann Marie, "as someone who got a 780 on the verbal SAT, I find these analogies very hard."
I come over and look at the Nine-Year-Old's homework. It says:
journey is to trip as BLANK is to spin.
And I too go, "Huh?" The Nine-Year-Old has decided that BLANK is swirl. I am sure that is not what they are looking for. But I can think of nothing alternative that is significantly more compelling...
Posted by DeLong at October 22, 2002 06:39 PM | TrackbackGeez, on the SATs it's at least multiple choice.
Posted by: Jason McCullough on October 22, 2002 11:07 PMthis appears to be a question planted by your Mr Ashcroft's TRIPS programme in the Berkeley area. Suffice it to say that it is fortunate that your son did not answer "REVOLUTION"
Posted by: Daniel Davies on October 23, 2002 12:07 AMRotate?
Posted by: MJ Turner on October 23, 2002 01:37 AMLook at this as an opportunity to get in touch with your Calvin side-- make up a word.
I think perhaps everyone is forgetting that the test is aimed at nine-year-old children. Is it possible that they are simply looking for a synonym for "spin" that is seven letters long? "Revolve"?
Posted by: Jonathan Swift on October 23, 2002 05:51 AMI think perhaps everyone is forgetting that the test is aimed at nine-year-old children. Is it possible that they are simply looking for a synonym for "spin" that is seven letters long? "Revolve"?
Posted by: Jonathan Swift on October 23, 2002 05:52 AMhmmm, how about "rationalize" or "justify" ?
Posted by: David on October 23, 2002 06:01 AMThinking on, if these nine-year-old children were considered to be exceptionally gifted, then maybe an answer like "joyride" would be more appropriate?
I'm really glad I'm no longer nine.
Posted by: Jonathan Swift on October 23, 2002 06:20 AMThis is easy. First, "trip" and "journey" are simply synonyms. Second, remember the basic writer's trick: to indicate the degree of education of a character, use the appropriate ratio of Latin- to Germanic-origin words in their dialogue. "Journey" is Latin and "trip" and "spin" are Germanic. Latin synonyms for "spin" include rotate (but not revolve - this implies a center of rotation outside the object, e.g. the earth spins or rotates about its axis but revolves around the sun), protract, obfuscate, and (for physicists) rotational angular momentum (thrice Latin).
And people think these kinds of tests simply check a kid's intelligence. Hah! The answer's probably "Revolve", or maybe "Rotate," but if you ask me it should be "Drive". Journeys are long, trips are short. Drives (in the car) are long. Spins (in the car) are short. Least they were when I was growing up. Though I don't think Americans use the phrase "Going for a spin in the car."
Posted by: Kieran Healy on October 23, 2002 08:21 AMTwo quibbles; "Journey" is Norman French and only very distantly Latin, and the engine of my car turns over at 2000 revolutions per minute, not rotations.
Posted by: Daniel Davies on October 23, 2002 09:00 AMRegarding "revolve", mea culpa. In physics it's quite helpful to use the meanings of "rotate" and "revolve" that are distinct, but, as is typical in language, there are multiple meanings of "revolve", and one is a synonym for "rotate" or "spin".
Regarding "journey", my dictionary says it comes from "diurnus" ... I'm no linguist but it looks pretty direct to me.
Kieran,
"but if you ask me it should be "Drive". Journeys are long, trips are short. Drives (in the car) are long. Spins (in the car) are short. Least they were when I was growing up. Though I don't think Americans use the phrase "Going for a spin in the car."
That was my first reaction, but, on checking it out, it appears that "a trip" in the sense of a short journey is more British English than American English. In addition, I really could not think of a word to cover something longer than "a spin", apart that is from "journey." You're absolutely correct though, "drive" is perfect.
twirl
Posted by: on October 23, 2002 10:52 AMOK, I see it like this:
Journey is 7-letter, 2-syllable lame 80's band that had one hit album and is now on the county fair circuit. By subtracting the number of letters in the words journey (7) and trip (4) you get 3. This signifies the number lame albums released. Journey released one hit album, had the audacity to then release a Best of Album, followed by a recent album in an attempt to hang on. Since spin also has 4 letters. We need to find a 7-letter, 2-syllable lame 80's band that has 3 albums, an initial hit, a best of, and a pathetic current release that is on the county fair circiut. Hmmm...WARRANT! So there you have it.
journey is to trip as warrant is to spin
Posted by: BEM on October 23, 2002 11:31 AMPerhaps the spin has a political meaning. It could be journey is to trip as dissemble is to spin.
Posted by: Chris McGrath on October 23, 2002 12:58 PMJourney is to Trip as Rolling Stone Magazine is to Spin.
Posted by: david on October 23, 2002 07:20 PMBEM has a brilliant answer. If, however, you want to go with a blogger's approach, spin has a wholly different context. Perhaps leak or hype might fit better than twist, rotate, or revolve...
Posted by: Dave Roberts on October 24, 2002 03:30 PMSeems pretty obvious to me -- "journey" is just the unnecessarily fancy-pants way of saying "trip", so we're looking for the unnecessarily fancy-pants way of saying "spin" -- namely, "rotate". (Heh. Thought you were pretty smart, didn't you, you fancy-pants egghead Berkeley professor, huh? Huh?)
Posted by: Bruce Moomaw on November 2, 2002 12:37 AM