The Economist turns very gloomy about the U.S. economy in 2003--and the U.S. economy in 2003 is one of the brighter spots in the first-world economic picture...
Posted by DeLong at January 17, 2003 11:47 AM | TrackbackEconomist.com: ...The biggest obstacle to healthier economic performance, though, is political. As the Fed’s chairman, Alan Greenspan, acknowledged in the closing months of 2002, uncertainty about the future is holding both investors and consumers back. The shadowy threat of international terrorism and the much more explicit prospect of a war with Iraq has made many Americans nervous about the future. For businesses still reeling from the speed at which the late-1990s boom turned to bust, the political climate is one more reason to put off investing in new plant and equipment or hiring new staff. For consumers, for so long the mainstay of the American economy, the thrill of the shopping mall seems, finally, to be on the wane. On January 17th, the respected University of Michigan survey of consumer sentiment showed an unexpected drop because of gloomier expectations of future spending.
That’s certainly what some of the most recent figures imply. Eight out of 19 manufacturing industries showed a fall in production in December. Car production fell by 4.7%, possibly a sign that the boom in car sales—fed by discounts and interest-free promotions—has faded. Static or falling production is not a comfortable base from which to make decisions about upgrading factories.
Nor does it encourage companies to hire new workers or retain existing staff. Employment fell by 101,000 in December—a sign that upheavals in the labour market continued all the way through 2002. The fact that the unemployment rate stayed at 6% suggests some people have given up looking for work (and so are not counted in the jobless data). That might have contributed to the fall in initial unemployment claims too, although economists reckon that seasonal upheavals in working patterns make figures at this time of the year especially hard to assess.
It is hard to put a favourable interpretation on most of the data. But it is important to keep a sense of perspective. Some recent figures look disappointing partly because they fall short of over-optimistic forecasts—a persistent weakness of those paid to predict the economic future, no matter how often they are proved wrong. The Fed’s beige book confirms that the economy remains weak, but also reveals signs of pick-up in several regions, most notably the industrial north-east. And America is still among the fastest-growing of the big industrial economies.
Although we accurately predicted the beginning of the US recession, part of that American economic analysis was of course finger crossed guesswork, but predicting how long it will last is much more difficult due to the near random nature of actions by politicians and other members of the 'politburo'.
Will they increase/decrease taxes, increase/decrease spending, borrow or print money, restrict or free-up regulation, open or close international trade.... and so on. Predicting these is a coin flipping process compared to the prediction of mass effects of millions of individual choices which can be modelled using probabilities based on semi-random semi-independent partially rational actions.
I stick by our earlier analysis that the shallow recession seen so far just doesn't seem like the full consequences of the biggest bubble in American history. My guess is that all that insane investment must end up costing at least one year's normal growth and maybe two or three and so over say the next 10 years growth would probably be under trend (in total) by some 3% to 10%.
This could come in one big recession of 10% or 1% under trend for 10 years or some other combination. (All numbers being wild guesses here.)
With money printing, new regulations, trade restrictions and the official encouragement for Americans to go deeper into debt at this the worst possible moment, my guess is for a long low growth period lasting 5 to 10 years followed by a resumption of previous trend.
Editor http://thoughts.editthispage.com where we struggle to understand by doubting everything.
Posted by: Editor on January 21, 2003 11:28 AM